Cresskill, New Jersey · Since 1964

Jewelry worth
a closer look.

Engagement rings, wedding bands and fine jewelry, chosen with care and sold by people who know their stones. Come in, ask questions, and take your time.

Plan a visit Browse collections

Engagement specialistsHelp finding the right ring

Fair, honest pricingClear answers, no pressure

Knowledgeable staffGuidance on every stone

Family-run since 1964Three generations on Union Avenue

Collections

Something for every milestone

Engagement Rings

Solitaires, halos, three-stone and vintage-inspired settings. We'll walk you through cut, color, clarity and carat so you can choose with confidence.

Wedding Bands

Classic gold and platinum bands, diamond eternity rings and men's styles, with sizing to match your engagement ring.

Fine Jewelry

Diamond studs, pendants, bracelets and colored gemstones. Gifts for birthdays and anniversaries, or just because.

New · Design your own

Picture it, then build it

Pick a metal, a stone, a shape and a setting, and see your ring, pendant or earrings take shape. Save the design and bring it in.

Start designing

Services

Care for the pieces you love

Bring in a ring that needs resizing, a necklace with a broken clasp, or an idea for something new. Call ahead and we'll tell you what to expect.

Ask about a service

Custom design
Turn a sketch, a photo or a family stone into a finished piece. Start a design →
Ring sizing
Make a favorite ring fit comfortably again.
Jewelry repair
Clasps, chains, prongs and stone tightening.
Cleaning & inspection
Bring your ring back to its full sparkle and check that every stone is secure.

About us

On Union Avenue since 1964

In 1964, Ann Angeletti was driving through Cresskill when she spotted a small storefront for rent. She was curious, so she called to ask the price: $85 a month. That's how Curiosity Jewelers began.

More than sixty years later, Ann still comes to work six days a week (she was 101 when the national press caught up with her in 2025), running the store alongside her daughter and granddaughter. Our customers know us for engagement rings, a wide range of fine jewelry, clear answers and fair prices.

Read Ann's story in the press →